Friday 5 November 2021

Asking questions is a journalist's job

but only provided that the questions are used for legitimate purposes - such as obtaining information or querying the accuracy of information. 

Asking questions (and then using the answers) to simply stir up trouble is not a legitimate purpose. The journalist who asked President Macron the question as to whether  he thought Prime Minister Morrison had lied to him was simply stirring up trouble. There were other ways the topic could have been approached but this was done deliberately. It was done to further criticise the Downunder Prime Minister and show him as being as incompetent as possible.

The reason for all this? The most likely reason for all this is that he is not doing what is expected of him or, if he is, he is not doing it in the way which is expected of him. He isn't demanding the immediate end of all coal fired power stations and banning all coal mining. Of course if he did do that then he would be accused of wrecking the economy and not supporting "poor" countries which rely on coal fired power stations.  The Prime Minister is in a situation where he cannot win.

I wonder though if the journalist who asked the question really thought about what he was doing. What he has done is put at risk the livelihoods of many other people in this country who need to trade with the rest of the world. By deliberately inflaming the situation he has put trade negotiations at risk. He has, perhaps irreparably, harmed the economy. It might get the journalist a few minutes of fame and a pat on the back from the news service which employs him but if other contracts are cancelled then it does no good at all. The economic harm done by the question is likely to be immense. Is it legitimate to deliberately choose to ask questions designed to do that?

5 comments:

Frances said...

Isn't the general wish, here and worldwide, only that Scott Morrison, as head of government, aims to phase out such as coal fired power stations and coal mining by 2050?
I follow this issue quite closely, and I find your comment strange. No mainstream media, or any alternatives that I have seen is expecting from him the actions that you suggest, ie, closing down coal mines or banning coal mine.

Anonymous said...

I think Cat is absolutely right. We are being told to close down coal mines and coal fired power plants. We are also being told to do a lot of other things that will wreck the economy. We are also being told to do them by people who are not doing what they pledged to do. Australia met ALL the targets from the Paris Accord but we are copping more criticisms than other developed nations. Chris

Frances said...

The word I objected to was "immediate".

Frances said...

Catriona. I cannot believe you allow comments by people unwilling to identify themself.


catdownunder said...

Frances, it was not an "anonymous" comment. I know who Chris is. He has commented here before.
Your own comments on this blog have almost always been critical. It is up to me whether I allow comments from "anonymous" people.